Good afternoon, We've setup a mailman list to make discussion of the results of the IMUDI paper reviews easier. All PC members were auto-subscribed to the list. We've also setup a conference call for tomorrow morning (10am CDT) for anybody that would like to discuss the results of the papers on the phone instead of via email. The coordinates for that call are: Date and Time: 6/24/2011 @ 10am CDT Phone Number: 570-639-6055 Passcode: 379562# We've attached the initial ranking of the paper reviews below. There are a couple of missing reviews. If you haven't sent us your review(s) yet, and won't be able to do so by early tomorrow morning (8am CDT), please let us know so that we can ensure that all papers have the proper number of reviews (3). RANK Paper # Title 1 (#2) Noncollective Communicator Creation in MPI 2 (#4) Leveraging C++ Meta-Programming 3 (#6) Evaluation of Interpreted Languages with Open MPI 4 (#5) Towards Software-level Virtual Experimentation of MPI-based Million-way Concurrency 5 (#3) A Lightweight C++ Interface to MPI 6 (#1) A Transformation in MPI for topology-aware mapping from Process Topology to Network Topology Currently, it looks like we'll accept the first 3-4 papers. Papers #2,#4 and #6 have unanimous accept. Paper #1 has unanimous reject. Paper #3 was reviewed as reject and two times weak accept. Paper #5 has mixed reviews (definite accept, reject) but is still missing a review. I've attached paper #5 for those who want to take a closer look at the paper. We'll send out an update as soon as we obtain the 3rd review for paper #5. Thanks, Jason Cope and Dries Kimpe