August 2010 - Icpads-2010-storage - mailman3.cels.anl.gov

ICPADS MDSS track review completed and recommendation sent out
by Chen, Yong 24 Aug '10

24 Aug '10

Dear All, We thank you so much again for your time and your excellent reviews. We have completed the MDSS track review process - we received all required 48 reviews, with 4 reviews for each paper in our track. Based on review comments and review evaluations, we have made the recommendation to program chairs - with 6 papers recommended to be presented in the conference and the rest 6 papers rejected. Enclosed please find our recommendations sent to program chairs. We have also requested program chairs to strongly encourage the authors to address the issues and concerns mentioned in reviews when sending out the acceptance letter. We appreciate your valuable effort to the ICPADS conference. We also look forward to the opportunity to work with you together again in the future. Thank you. --Rob and Yong ________________________________________ From: Chen, Yong Sent: Thursday, August 19, 2010 9:18 PM To: icpads-2010-storage(a)lists.mcs.anl.gov Cc: rross(a)mcs.anl.gov Subject: Reminder: ICPADS review discussion closed at 5 p.m. PST, 8/22 Dear All, This is a kind reminder that the review discussion deadline is 5 p.m. PST, 8/22, Sunday. We appreciate you take a look of other reviews, if you haven't done that yet, to avoid potential misjudgment/reduce the disparity if possible. Thank you! --Rob and Yong

1 0

Reminder: ICPADS review discussion closed at 5 p.m. PST, 8/22
by Chen, Yong 19 Aug '10

19 Aug '10

Dear All, This is a kind reminder that the review discussion deadline is 5 p.m. PST, 8/22, Sunday. We appreciate you take a look of other reviews, if you haven't done that yet, to avoid potential misjudgment/reduce the disparity if possible. Thank you! --Rob and Yong ________________________________________ From: Chen, Yong Sent: Monday, August 16, 2010 12:57 PM To: icpads-2010-storage(a)lists.mcs.anl.gov Cc: rross(a)mcs.anl.gov Subject: ICPADS review discussion enabled Dear All, We have enabled the review discussion - please take a moment to read other reviewers' comments . We especially would like to reduce the disparity among reviews. A few papers listed in the following have a large variation among reviews. If you are one of the reviewers of these papers, we appreciate you take a look and make changes if necessary. 34, "VND: A Virtual Network-based Disk for Virtual Machines" 43, PicFS: The Privacy-enhancing Image-based Collaborative File System 68, ACM: Availability-aware Cache Management for Improving RAID Reconstruction Performance Also, if you haven't completed all reviews yet, we appreciate you provide the reviews soon. Thanks again for your time. Your effort is valuable to the success of the ICPADS conference. --Rob and Yong

1 0

ICPADS review discussion enabled
by Chen, Yong 16 Aug '10

16 Aug '10

Dear All, We have enabled the review discussion - please take a moment to read other reviewers' comments . We especially would like to reduce the disparity among reviews. A few papers listed in the following have a large variation among reviews. If you are one of the reviewers of these papers, we appreciate you take a look and make changes if necessary. 34, "VND: A Virtual Network-based Disk for Virtual Machines" 43, PicFS: The Privacy-enhancing Image-based Collaborative File System 68, ACM: Availability-aware Cache Management for Improving RAID Reconstruction Performance Also, if you haven't completed all reviews yet, we appreciate you provide the reviews soon. Thanks again for your time. Your effort is valuable to the success of the ICPADS conference. --Rob and Yong ________________________________________ From: Chen, Yong Sent: Sunday, August 08, 2010 10:09 PM To: icpads-2010-storage(a)lists.mcs.anl.gov Cc: rross(a)mcs.anl.gov Subject: Reminder: ICPADS reviews needed by 8/15 Dear All, This is a kind reminder that the ICPADS reviews are due on 8/15. We appreciate you provide timely reviews for this conference so we can proceed for the review discussion and make the recommendation for the decision on time too. Thank you! -- Rob and Yong

1 0

Reminder: ICPADS reviews needed by 8/15
by Chen, Yong 08 Aug '10

08 Aug '10

Dear All, This is a kind reminder that the ICPADS reviews are due on 8/15. We appreciate you provide timely reviews for this conference so we can proceed for the review discussion and make the recommendation for the decision on time too. Thank you! -- Rob and Yong ________________________________________ From: icpads-2010-storage-bounces(a)lists.mcs.anl.gov [icpads-2010-storage-bounces(a)lists.mcs.anl.gov] On Behalf Of Chen, Yong [cheny(a)ornl.gov] Sent: Saturday, July 10, 2010 3:14 PM To: icpads-2010-storage(a)lists.mcs.anl.gov Subject: [ICPADS-2010-storage] paper assigned - please return reviews by 8/15 Dear All, We have completed the paper review assignment. Each member is assigned with 4 papers. You should be able to see these 4 review assignments when you login the conference management system: https://cmt2.research.microsoft.com/ICPADS2010/Default.aspx. If you like to have an external reviewer, you may do so by using "add external reviewer" feature on the website, but the conference encourages the PC member does the majority of the work. Enclosed please also find a copy of the instructions for reviewers from the conference organizers. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact us. We appreciate you return the reviews on time by 8/15. Thank you again for your time. -- Rob and Yong

1 0