On Thu, 26 Nov 2009 09:26:41 -0600 (CST), Satish Balay <[email protected]> wrote:
BTW: What exact error message do you get?
It was this one, but it's working correctly now. The environmental variable PETSC_DIR /home/jedbrow/petsc-dev is not a directory This system is actively hostile in the sense that there are different incompatible core tools scattered everywhere, the error came before I fixed up LD_LIBRARY_PATH and such to get consistent libs. The error was probably caused by that nonsense, sorry for the noise.
peraps this is one case where --prefix install is useful?
I'm not sure, I want the source to stick around for debugging purposes and to make rebuilding easier. I think --prefix is good for everything that you only want one version of, or that you don't expect any useful debugging information from. It is pretty much the only sensible thing for desktop and core libs, the alternative is that you're constantly monkeying with LD_LIBRARY_PATH, or building with RPATH in which case a libc upgrade means rebuilding/downloading all of userland. This is the reason for the Debian/GNU guidelines. A lot of clusters manage multiple MPI implementations built with multiple ABI-incompatible compilers plus (if you're lucky) some debug builds for a core set of libraries. This works, but administering all of these builds and building new software becomes a lot more work. When a library is near the top of the stack and the value of having multiple versions present is greater than the effort of managing them, PETSc's no-prefix system works well (but any system that cleanly handles out-of-source builds would be fine too). There are applications for which PETSc is just another library and users want to 'aptitude install petsc' and have it Just Work. We might argue that they just don't know what they want, but it can be a hard sell. Some of these build systems are only designed for a single in-source build which is an insult to any precocious users who thinks they might want more than one version of PETSc. This is where the --prefix install comes in (and a pkg-config file would be nice too). Jed